looking at them as elemental beings earth and fire read as there element well, water is nise but i it reads more as a water creature, wind i dint even read as the element, without reading the tittle(which i dint >_>) i figured it out only when i was doing the survey but they are all great
I chose fire, for it appeared the most balanced. I love the knees and fire hair the most!
The water is my least favorite, as it seems too jumbled and less aesthetically pleasing for me. Some aspects of the design were great (the belt and robe), as I love how they seem a part of his body somehow. Air was probably my third choice, as the concept is really interesting, but I felt some aspects of the design clashed with each other rather than compliment. Earth was my second, and probably would of been my first choice, but it was the least intriguing of them all I think. Though it's balance and general design was the best executed I think.
So I think each one had something interesting and fitting, but overall, parts of their design seemed to clash and disrupt the overall flow for me.